Recorded the week after the September critique, with two people who sat through it.
- The two questions: what were you going for, and where did it stop going there?
- The critique runs once a month inside The Lanternfield Room.

What a monthly critique is really for, and the two questions I ask before I say anything about anyone’s picture.
Recorded the week after the September critique, with two people who sat through it.
Hello. This is Available Light. I am Ray. And this one was recorded the week after the September critique with two people who sat through it. Amina and Sophia are both in the portrait critique circle. Twelve images this month, and the same note on eight of them, which we will get to. First, what a critique is for. I ask two questions before I say anything about anyone's picture. What were you going for? And where did it stop going there? Everything useful comes out of those two. Amina, the first time you brought a picture, what did you expect? I expected to be told whether it was good, and instead you asked what I wanted. And I realized I did not know. I had taken a nice picture by accident, and I wanted someone to confirm the accident. For me, it was the second question. Where did it stop going there? I could point to the exact spot. The light was right, the face was right, and then the hands were doing nothing. I had never looked at my own picture long enough to see the hands. The note this month on eight of twelve, the person is too close to the window, not too far, too close. The near side of the face is blown out, and the far side is fine, so people think they need more light. They need the person to take two steps back, so the light has room to wrap. Mine was one of the eight. I had read your post about standing close, and I overdid it. Two steps back, and the next week, it was a different picture. So, how to look at your own pictures, print them small, put them on a table, and walk past them for a week? The ones that keep stopping you are the ones. And ask yourself the two questions out loud if you have to. Sophia, what changed for you? I stopped asking people if they liked it. I ask them what they think I was going for. If they cannot tell, the picture is not finished, whether or not they like it. Critique is the third Thursday of every month in the circle. Bring one picture, not six. Thank you both. Thanks for listening.