Two pictures, two questions, no mercy and no cruelty.
- What were you going for?
- Where did it stop going there?
The pictures are in the Portrait Critique Circle resources so you can look while you listen.

Amina and Sofia each bring one picture, and we do the whole thing on the microphone: the two questions, the hands, the two steps back.
Two pictures, two questions, no mercy and no cruelty.
The pictures are in the Portrait Critique Circle resources so you can look while you listen.
Welcome to Available Light. I am Rae and this is the episode I was slightly dreading, A Critique Out Loud. Amina and Sophia have each brought one picture. They are in the circle resources if you want to look while you listen and we are going to do the whole thing on the microphone. Amina, you first. What were you going for? A portrait of my neighbor in her hallway. There is a skylight and the light comes straight down and I wanted the picture to feel like the hallway feels which is calm and a bit like a church. And where did it stop going there? Her eyes. The light is from above so her eyes are dark. The hallway is calm and she looks tired. That is exactly it and you found it yourself which is the point of the two questions. Light from straight above is the one direction that does nothing for a face. The fix is not more light. It is a bounce from below. A white towel on the floor or ask her to look up at the skylight for one frame. A man in a doorway. Overcast day. After your episode about overcast. I was going for the bright side and the quiet side. You got it. The face is right. Where did it stop? His hands again. They are in his pockets. He looks like he is waiting for a bus. Hands are the thing nobody looks at until it is too late. Pockets read as waiting. Give him a door frame to lean on or a mug or the dog. Anything that gives the hands a reason. The rest of the picture is finished which is why the hands show. Can I say what I noticed in Sophia's? The quiet side is a bit too quiet. There is no detail in the shadow at all. Good. That is a white wall opposite the doorway or a step closer to the open side. And that is the whole method. Two questions and then the people in the room say what they see. Critique is the third Thursday of the month in the circle. Bring one picture not six and have your answer to the first question ready. Thank you both for doing this out loud. Next time I am bringing the hands.